Thoughts on Pet Insurance
Was wondering if anyone has pet insurance for their pups. I was looking into it, and still on the fence if I should make that investment. It seems as if most just cover accidents. Would like some input pretty please!
Comments
The other day I was forced to go to the emergency clinic after hours because Sabre had her second puppy stuck. I called and told them I would be there ASAP and hoped they would be ready for her. I knew the puppy was still alive but if left there in its current position for much longer it wouldn't. Normally my wife can reach the puppy and guide it out with her small hands during the contractions. However, this puppy was very big and coming out breach which makes it harder to get a hold of.
Anyhow I hauled Butt to the emergency clinic on Sunday. The receptionist must have known I was coming in also because she said, "Is this Sabre? OK, well I need you to fill out some forms." I was like my wife can fill out the forms, I need a c-section right now. She said well you're going to have to wait until the doctor comes out. My patience grew thin after 10 minutes as I listened to Sabre contract and whine in pain while laying on the waiting room floor. I told the receptionist I needed to see the doctor now because I feared for the life of Sabre and her puppies. The receptionist stormed off angry. She then came back and said follow me to a room. Once I got in the room she left again as I stood there holding Sabre. A minute later the Vet stormed in and immediately said "Listen I'm going to take care of your dog but you better stop being an ASS to my tech." I was shocked and replied saying I'm not being an ass at all... She interrupted me and said my Vet said you almost had her in tears. I then had to tell her to just please conduct the c-section. She immediately continued and said "First of all my concern is with Sabre not the puppies, and I'm not going to do a c-section until I thoroughly examine her." After her exam she looked at me and said "One of the puppies is stuck and she needs to have a c-section." I bit my lip on allowing myself to say "No Shit." I asked her if it would be ok for either my wife or myself to be present during the surgery so we could properly care for the puppies after they were taken out. She said "NO, I'll have my Tech bring you the puppies."
About 20 minutes later in walks the Tech with 4 puppies, all with their tongues hanging out and barely breathing. The Tech walked out of the room and my wife and I began clearing the water from their mouths and lungs. 2 of the puppies were turning white face and losing blood flow. We both worked hard to save one of them which we got breathing. However, by the time I got to the big brindle (the one that was stuck) he had already passed. I took about 3 of the rubber gloves on the counter and started filling them with hot water and tied them off. I placed the 3 puppies in a large towel and set them down on the warm ballooned gloves. A little while later in walks the Tech asking how the puppies were doing. I told her we lost one and she then grabbed the puppy and said "Well the Vet is almost done stitching up Sabre so I'll have her take a look at him." I guess my opinion of a deceased puppy wasn't taken with complete trust.
By the time Sabre came out I was so happy just to see her and the only thing I could think about was paying the $1500 bill and getting her and her puppies on out of there. I couldn't help to notice the large butchered job they called stitches. Geez, couldn't even cut a straight line or stitch it back on with care and pride. Utterly disappointing and unsatisfactory.
On a positive note Sabre, the 3 puppies born from c-section, and the one puppy born naturally are all doing excellent.
No Phil, I'm not too thrilled with the Vets around here either!
"It's not just a Dog, it's a Bull Terrier!"
www.bulliesofnc.com
My normal Vet I use for vaccinations is a real nice guy but he's not into anything other than normal procedures. The first day I went to him as I was hoping from one Vet to another in hopes of finding a really good Vet I asked him "Do you conduct BAER Testing?" He said "Never heard of it." I told him what it was and he said you should be able to clap your hands and determine if a puppy can hear you or not so there's really no need for a detailed test. He then went on to say he's been to many Vet medical classes and meetings each year and never heard of a BAER test.
I'm confident that the normal expenses required for the proper medical attention don't equate to the annual charges of the insurance. I could be wrong but I've heard from others that it's a money making scheme with loop holes. Maybe Trent from Blitzkrieg Bullies could shed some light on the costs, savings, or opposite.
"It's not just a Dog, it's a Bull Terrier!"
www.bulliesofnc.com
Poor Sabre, that's some awful vet care!
I also have a distaste for banfield practices. I've heard some true horror stories about dogs( and I mean excessive numbers at the same location) dying or becoming severely ill after very routine surgeries. I've also seen someone who was charged $500+ for procedures that they had not even been contacted to "ok"- all the owner had done is drop off the dog for shots and a check up. I'm not saying every vet at this company is bad, but many just care about their pockets and I've seen little good from them.
I recently was looking into pet insurance, however it seems all the insurances I've looked at do not cover anything to do with breeding (so no coverage for emergency C-sec) or congenital defects your dog may have. They seem to be best for either preventative care and some emergency situations.
Steve, I'm glad to hear Sabre and surviving pups are doing well despite the hack job. What a shame the stuck-pup was lost. It sounds like there was a possibility it might have had a better chance if the vet had a sense of urgency and you were allowed to be present to assist
"It's not just a Dog, it's a Bull Terrier!"
www.bulliesofnc.com
"It's not just a Dog, it's a Bull Terrier!"
www.bulliesofnc.com
I guess I have a different mentality because my capital is constantly working for me.
My upfront (waiting on reimbursement), premium and deductible costs would be invested elsewhere compounding my investment over and over many times while I'm "hoping for the best" with my well cared for pet's health.
My investments are sure things, being careless and letting Stoeger launch himself off a balcony has a slightly lower chance of happening.
If we are going to use the "I think I can fly puppy" example... I'd set up a facebook and beg for donations before pet insurance. After begging and pleading for help, the owner came out of pocket close to what she would have to do with insurance. Probably with less hassle than dealing with an insurance company. Oh and if she had pet insurance, she would have to have this outstanding, number one rated company you found. If not, would the story be much the same!?!?
So far it sounds like your insurance company has been very good at taking your money (they're investing it btw), lemme know when you actually have a claim. Your argument will have much more validity when you have a reimbursement check in your hand.
http://www.yelp.com/biz/healthy-paws-pet-insurance-and-foundation-bellevue-2
Keep in mind that most people generally write a review to complain, so most, over the top rave reviews can be discounted as phoney and written by an employee.
Stoeger, I agree whole heartedly! Solid thought.
If there WERE a policy that cost $25.00 a month per dog and actually covered anything worthwhile I'd pay it in a heartbeat... hell, our dogs chew $25.00 worth of Bully Sticks in a week!
Veterinarians are 80% business and 20% skill.... At the passing of our last girl we spend over $8000 in 3 weeks from the first trip to the emergency to the local vet, to our original (most trustyworth) vet 85 miles away, to the giant corporate surgery center, none could save her, although, I believe she could have been saved if ANY of them knew what they were doing. So, when desperate care is needed fast, like with Steve's Saber, I hope you all have somewhere competent to go, and don't find out the reality of performance out there when a loved one's life is on the line.
My investments routinely return 50%, 75% and 100% and turn within 30 days.
Like I said, my mentality is different than others and so are my investments.
Some of the product I sell are of the insurance or warranty type. Large profit is derived through the cost of the premium (which is due up front, no monthly payments) and the game is on when a claim rolls in.
Luckily, I'm only a middle man with those products. The customer and insurance company battle it out from there.
Like I said, until you have a claim reimbursement check in hand.... You're just "hoping for the best".
I in no way have directed you in how to care for your beautiful girl, no need, you're doing a wonderful job.
But for you to slap an insurance company on the back and thump your chest with how great pet insurance is without having filed a claim is a bit preposterous.
I think there's Pro's and Con's to both aspects of paying for insurance vice out of pocket payment. I think I made myself clear on being neutral on this subject and based on the opinions provided by both sides there's enough information for others to make a intelligent decision on whether or not they wish to carry pet insurance for their beloved Bull Terrier.
I don't think this needs to turn into a debate and I don't think anyone had any intentions of criticizing someone's decisions on what is best for their dog. The best decision will always be the one that the owner feels most comfortable with.
"It's not just a Dog, it's a Bull Terrier!"
www.bulliesofnc.com
- agree with your desire to make sure Maya is cared for in a special way.
Kiko is signed up for TruPanion since we got her. http://trupanion.com/
We have the basic plan - one never knows what a bully might ingest or get themselves into.
However, our vet has sent them a STINKING letter on our behalf, pointing out that what they are saying in effect is that we should have driven a very sick dog for over an hour just to fit their approved list. On top of that, he has stated that if they do not pay the claim, he will remove all their literature from his practice and actively warn customer NOT to register their animals with them.
I am old enough and wise enough to know that the chances of them reversing their decision are small – but I have to take my hat off to the vet for what he has done for us. We are so lucky that we have a vet who grew up with Bull Terriers and truly loved BIkkel – the only time I have ever heard vet get emotional was when I called him to let him know that Bikkel had gone.
@Bulliesof NC what a horrendous experience with Sabre – my blood was boiling at ever sentence. But good to hear that she is doing well now.
PS Insurance company for any Dutch/Belgian members is Proteq
"It's not just a Dog, it's a Bull Terrier!"
www.bulliesofnc.com
How has this fraud not been impeached yet?
pgreid sorry for your loss.
"It's not just a Dog, it's a Bull Terrier!"
www.bulliesofnc.com
If it wasn't for Bullies there would be little to live for anymore, n'est-ce pas?
Titan is almost as prone to injuring himself as I am but accident only coverage is out of the question because since he’s a Bull Terrier he’s at risk for genetic health problems like kidney disease, heart disease, deafness, patella luxation, skin and fur issues and more. These issues are not cheap to treat and in the case of chronic heart or kidney disease you’re potentially looking at lifetime treatment costs.
So IMO don’t bother with companies that exclude hereditary and congenital health issues. I know 2 out of 3 Nationwide (used to be VPI) plans don’t really cover the genetic stuff and petpremium and aspca plans are the same. I think those companies offer one plan that’s more comprehensive but overall the customer reviews on those 3 are pretty discouraging.
Here in the states, I've found that Healthy Paws, Trupanion, Embrace and PetPlan are among the best when it comes to purebreds like Bull Terriers
Depending on where you’re located I can probably point you to a few companies worth checking out.
Here's some resources that I've been looking at, again many of these are only in the states but others like Petplan and Healthy Paws have coverage that extends to the UK and Canada, respectively. Feel free to send me a private message too.
http://www.thebullterrierclub.
http://files.dvm360.com/
https://www.petinsuranceu.com/
Here, in Perú (South America), there are not such things as pet insurance. There is a private company thinking in developing one but nothing yet. Well if human health insurance are expensive, I can't imagine how expensive is going to be the insurance for pets.
I read the entire conversation and kept me thinking of the quality of veterinarians around here, and mainly they're promoted by mouth to mouth. The average cost of vaccinations are like 15 to 20 dollars. I spent like 10 dollars each month for the antiflees pipett, 5 dollars for deparasitation (sorry if its not the correct word), and 10 dollars for bath, nail clipping. The price for consultation is 10 dollars, and we pay for the medicine. Just in my neighborhood there are like 10 veterinarians/pet stores/pet spa (yes, they do everything).
I know that bigger procedures cost a lot more. And unfortunately, there
are not that much specialist here. I know someone who spend 1000
dollars, his dog spent 20 days in the clinic before passing away, had two blood
transfussions, blood exams every three days, and ecographies. Sadly,
there was nothing it can be done for the dog as she accidentally ate
human medicines and wasn't treated in time. The cost for spaying are around 40 to 80 dollars, it depends. Don't know the cost around the globe.
I don't think that many people are interested in taking a pet insurance, maybe is a cultural thing, as not everyone have a private health insurace (the government health insurance is terrible you can die before you get an appointment or a bed in the emergency room). So if one not invest in themselves I don't think they're going to invest in their pets. There is no prevention culture here.
On the other hand, there are beautiful initiative that give attention to abandoned dogs and the dogs of poor people who doesn't have the money or the knowledge to vaccinate or treat their pets, there are spaying campains at social cost (5 soles, which are like 2 dollars), and vaccinations campains (rabies) at no cost. And some veterinarians give "social cost" for rescued dogs, so there are alternative if you don't have the resources (not a lot, but you can try).
We're progressing in terms of animal care. This year the law for pet mistreatment was approved, so a person who mistreated or abandon a pet could be in jail for four years. On the other hand, we still have bull-fighting and rooster-fighting, so the two sides of the coin. Sorry, I think I'm going out of subject.
Well, this is the view from someone from a country without pet insurance, you guys are lucky to have some options.